Column: Evaluating Sonia: black box leader

Mar 23 2013, 00:35 IST
Comments 0
SummaryShould Ms Sonia Gandhi, the ruler of the Congress party, be congratulated for finishing 15 years in Indian politics? It is not a sign of expertise if an heir becomes king.

Ms Gandhi has ruled over the largest democracy, over a billion people, for 9 years, and has yet to hold a press conference

Should Ms Sonia Gandhi, the ruler of the Congress party, be congratulated for finishing 15 years in Indian politics? It is not a sign of expertise if an heir becomes king. So why should it be different with Sonia?

What does Ms Gandhi’s political record look like? She formally assumed power in April 1998; but a year earlier (March 31, 1997, to be precise), the Congress party under the leadership of Sonia (or the formal head Sitaram Kesri?) had withdrawn support to the United Front government. As the accompanying table shows, the Congress obtained the same seats as 1996, but 3 percentage points less votes than the Narsimha Rao 1996 election. The next year, after a full 18 months in power, Sonia’s Congress obtained the lowest seats ever, 114, but kept its vote share equal to the 1996 level.

The same story continued for the next two elections. In 2009, the vote share remained just a notch below the 1996 level, even though the Congress won 206 seats. Note that vote share is an important indicator of a political party’s popularity; the seat share an important indicator of coalition politics. Note also the joint vote share of the Congress and the BJP was the lowest in the coalition-era world, post 1984. Thus, whatever the causes, it was not Sonia’s or the Congress’s popularity that led to its outsized win in 2009.

After the 2009 election, it was quite apparent that Sonia and the party were targeting 273 seats on their own. Given that the vote share had stayed broadly constant, and below the 1996 level, this belief in Congress’s invincibility is not suggestive of political prowess. Thus, the bottom line is quite straight forward—there is nothing in the record to suggest that Sonia has been a successful politician—except (and this is an important but) the vital fact that she is the glue that keeps the Congress together.

There is one other aspect of Sonia politics that deserves emphasis. As is commonly believed, the strongest threat to Congress’s popularity and continuation in power is the threat from BJP’s Narendra Modi. The Congress, and Sonia, have recognised this threat for several years, which is why in the 2007 state elections Sonia coined the phrase ‘Maut ka Saudagar’ or ‘Merchant of Death’ to describe Modi’s

Single Page Format
Ads by Google
Reader´s Comments
| Post a Comment
Please Wait while comments are loading...