Breaking his silence on the brewing row, Chief Justice of India R M Lodha on Tuesday disapproved of the PM Narendra Modi-led NDA governments move to unilaterally segregate former Solicitor General Gopal Subramanium from the panel of four names recommended for appointment as Supreme Court judges by the collegium and said it was not proper.
The first thing I had taken objection to was the segregation of Gopal Subramaniums file unilaterally by the executive. It is not proper, said the CJI. I, as the CJI, and four senior colleagues in the collegium spotted the best talent, who in our opinion would be good judges. We forwarded four names to the executive for appointment on May 6, he said.
On my return from abroad on June 28, a file was placed before me by the Ministry of Law and Justice, indicating that out of the four names, three proposals had been approved and the name of Gopal Subramanium was segregated. It was done unilaterally... without my knowledge and consent, said the CJI at a farewell function for Justice B S Chauhan who retired on Tuesday.
Do not bear the impression that the independence of the judiciary has been compromised. What really shocked me were questions regarding the independence of the judiciary. I have always fought for it and I will be the first person to leave this chair if it is compromised. I promise 1.2 billion people of India that independence of the judiciary will not be compromised, he said.
When contacted, Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad said, Our government has the highest regard for the judiciary and its independence and profound respect for the Chief Justice of India. Beyond this, I have no comment to offer.
The collegium recommended Subramaniums name along with the names of senior advocate Rohington Nariman, Calcutta High Court Chief Justice Arun Mishra and Orissa High Court Chief Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel for elevation to the Supreme Court.
While the three other names were cleared, Subramaniums elevation was blocked by the Modi government following a negative report by the CBI questioning his propriety as SG in the 2G case and his alleged links with former corporate lobbyist Niira Radia, whose intercepted phone conversations are under CBI scrutiny.
Subsequently, in his letter to the CJI on June 25, Subramanium withdrew his candidature, alleging that the government feared he would not toe their line and hence it ran a propaganda to mark him as