Facebook Pixel Code

Selloff an overhang

Stake divestment to pressure stock; mines are long-term. We see government divestment of its 9.5% stake in NTPC as a potential stock overhang given the weak execution at NTPC, its rich valuation and that re-allocation of three coal-mines is only a long-term catalyst at best.

Weak execution record and rich valuation cloud positives

Stake divestment to pressure stock; mines are long-term. We see government divestment of its 9.5% stake in NTPC as a potential stock overhang given the weak execution at NTPC, its rich valuation and that re-allocation of three coal-mines is only a long-term catalyst at best.

A potential hike in the float to 25% (15.5%) could pressure the shares and has been one reason for our Underperform rating. The government is working to hike LIC’s investment limit to 30% vs 10% as LIC, which bought most of the qualified institutional placement (QIP) in NTPC?s last follow-on public offer (FPO) already owns over 6%.

The NTPC stock has underperformed the market by 18% YTD (year-to-date) despite it being a consensus Buy (55% brokers).

We reiterate our non-consensus Underperform (13% brokers), as its slow growth (9% till ’17e) on poor execution may de-rate its expensive regulated utility multiples (1.6x P/BV?price-to-book value) esp. given that a peaked FY14e (estimates) RoE (return on equity) of 13.8%, negative FCF (free cash flow) and lower yield (3% vs SJVN’s 5%), could cap upside apart from government divestment.

Govt to divest 9.5% stake; Will mine catalyst work? NTPC?s last FPO in Feb?10 was subscribed by LIC, which bought 50% of the offer (2.5% of 5% offered) i.e. the entire QIB portion at R209/share (vs floor at R201). Post-FPO, LIC sold 39% in one month. The stock is now trading at 22% below the LIC FPO bid price. To create catalysts, government announced the return of three cancelled coal mines with reserves of 826mt ahead of divestment. This is only a long term trigger as these mines are unlikely start meaningful production before FY15. Meanwhile, EPS growth is likely to slow materially over FY14-17e on poor execution, fuel issues and delay in equipment orders.

Negative catalysts are: (i) delay in capex?management almost halved NTPC FY13-17e group new capacity, which adds to execution delays by its Russian vendors & bulk order, impacting its PAT/RoE (profit after tax/return on equity) growth, (ii) fuel shortages impacting incentives/RoE, and (iii) rich valuation. Pick-up in power/coal capex are positive catalysts.

Price objective: Our price objective of R153 for NTPC is based on DCF (discounted cash flow) based valuation. We have assumed WACC (weighted average cost of capital) of 10.3%.

Downside risks: (i) delay in project execution due to infrastructure bottlenecks & working challenges with new vendors,

(ii) risk of fuel supply to existing/ new plants, (iii) potential cut in RoE with likely improved demand-supply gap of power, (iv) potential entry into unrelated businesses (boilers) and (v) increased competition from the private sector.

Upside risks: A pick-up in capex/coal capex and higher than 15.5% RoE on gross-up of income tax.

BofA ML

Get live Share Market updates, Stock Market Quotes, and the latest India News and business news on Financial Express. Download the Financial Express App for the latest finance news.

First published on: 03-12-2012 at 01:34 IST
Market Data
Market Data
Today’s Most Popular Stories ×